Is There Evidence That Jesus Was More Than Just A Man?

Last Updated: July 3, 2023By Tags:

Recently, we’ve been discussing who Jesus of Nazareth was. We’ve also explored his own personal claims as to his identity. The truth is, though, that people can freely say whatever they want. But, when they make claims like being the all-powerful creator of the universe, we think them crazy unless there is some evidence to back that up. Did Jesus give any evidence that he was God? Or, did he just go around saying things and telling people to just believe what he said?

Jesus Performed Many Miracles

The eyewitnesses to Jesus’ life and ministry documented approximately 37 occasions when Jesus performed what we would call supernatural feats. He engaged with the world around him in ways that cannot be attributed to scientific trickery or illusion. These miracles can be grouped into 4 categories. Here are some of them

  • Environmental Manipulation – Turning water into wine (John 2:1-11), calming a storm at sea (Matthew 8:23-27, Mark 4:35-41, Luke 8:22-25)), feeding 5,000+ on 5 loaves of bread and 2 fish (Matthew 14:13-21, Mark 6:30-44, Luke 9:10-17, John 6:1-15)
  • Authority over the Supernatural Realm – a man with an unclean spirit in Capernaum (Mark 1:21-27, Luke 4:31-36), casting demons into pigs (Matthew 8:28-33, Mark 5:1-20, Luke 8:26-39), a boy with an unclean spirit (Matthew 17:14-20, Mark 9:14-29, Luke 9:37-43)
  • Ability To Heal Extreme Conditions – a Centurion’s paralyzed servant (Matthew 8:5-13, Luke 7:1-10), a man with a withered hand (Matthew 12:9-1, Mark 43:1-6, Luke 6:6-11), a servant’s severed ear while he is being arrested (Luke 22:50-51)

Healing is by far the biggest group of miracles Jesus performed (21). And it would be easy to dismiss them as luck, superior knowledge of healing, or even con artistry. We certainly see enough of this kind of thing in our present age. Thankfully, though, the eyewitnesses record many details about the preexisting conditions of the people who were healed. When Jesus healed people who were crippled, it wasn’t a guy with a sprained ankle – where the injuries were mostly minor and couldn’t be seen from the outside. These people had obvious physical deformities. Their ankles were turned inwards. Or their hands were withered. It’s one thing to see someone in a wheelchair who looks normal otherwise get wheeled up in front of a healer and be “healed”. It’s another to see that person get wheeled up on stage with their ankles sticking out at unnatural angles from their legs. Those are the kinds of people Jesus was healing.

  • Bringing People Back From The Dead – the widow’s son in Nain (Luke 7:11-17), Jairus’ daughter (Matthew 9:18,23-26; Mark 5:21-24,35-43; Luke 8:40-42,49-56), Lazarus (John 11:1-45)

Raising people from the dead is another one of those things that’s easy to dismiss. Our first thought might be that people wrongly assumed someone was dead when they were not. And, Jesus just kind of woke them up. I mean, I know if I saw someone lying very still, it would be easy for me to mistake them for dead if they hadn’t moved in quite a while.

Keep in mind, though, that 1st-century Jewish commoners had a lot more personal experience with dead bodies than we do. When someone we know dies, there is a medical examiner to verify the death, an ambulance to take the body to a funeral home, and a mortician to prepare the body. The majority of us never touch dead bodies. The Jews of the day did all that themselves, though. They knew what a dead body looked like and felt like. In the case of the widow’s son, Jesus stopped the funeral procession. So, he had been dead for some time. And, Lazarus had been dead for 4 days before Jesus got to him. Jesus even delayed so that there would be no question in peoples’ minds that Lazarus was dead by the time Jesus got there.

Jesus Predicted The Future

Jesus made many prediction about future events and these predictions came true. It would be easy to dismiss some of these claims as merely really good guesses. But, some of Jesus’ predictions were too specific and came true in too uncanny of ways for them to have been anything other than foreknowledge of future events.

A great number of Jesus’ predictions had to do with his last days. He seemed to know pretty clearly what his last days were going to look like. He predicted he was going to be betrayed, arrested, all of his followers would desert him and he would be executed. Some of these predictions might get dismissed as Jesus being able to read people really well or maybe he caught some rumors circulating about him and the plans the Jewish leaders had for him.

There is one prediction, however, that was too specific to be guessed beforehand. That was the way Peter denied him. It’s true that, if I had been spending most of my time with someone for 3 years, I could probably guess what they would do in a stressful situation. It’s one thing to say “if the cops question my buddy, Peter, he’s going to deny he knows me”. But, saying that he would be asked three times if he knew me and he would deny it three times – before the rooster crows – is prediction on a whole other level.

Jesus also predicted that he would be resurrected. And not only resurrected, he predicted that it would be on the third day after his execution (Matthew 16:21, Mark 8:31, Luke 9:22). Now, having a leader predict he would come back from the dead was nothing new. Alexander the Great said the same thing. And, he conspired with his friends to have them steal his body to make it look like he did. The Jewish leaders were onto this trick, though, which is why they demanded Pilate place a bunch of guards in front of Jesus’ tomb (Matthew 27:62-66).

Jesus predicted things that would come shortly after his death. He predicted that Jerusalem would be destroyed. And he predicted exactly how it would be done. He told the Pharisees that the city would be surrounded and the walls of the city would be torn down (Luke 19:43-44). Less than 40 years later, in 70 A.D., the Roman general Titus surrounded the city, laid siege to it, and leveled much of it. Many holy sites were demolished and relics carted off.

Related to this event was another of Jesus’ predictions. He predicted that the temple would be torn down (Matthew 24:1-2, Mark 13:2, Luke 21:6). As part of the sacking of Jerusalem, Titus destroyed the temple. All of the stones were cast down.

Jesus Came Back From The Dead

The final piece of evidence that Jesus gave regarding his identity was in his coming back from the dead. Many people had said they would come back, but Jesus actually did it. And, there’s a lot of great evidence to show that he did it. He predicted when he would die, how he would die, that he would come back from the dead, and on what day. Alternate theories have been proposed, of course. But none of them make much sense regarding the evidence we have.

Jesus Was An Evidentialist

Modern Christians often get characterized as having a faith that exists in spite of evidence to the contrary. This challenge comes because the person making it doesn’t understand what really counts as evidence and what the Biblical view of faith is. The word “faith” today conjures up images of simple people living in blissful ignorance of reality. People who believe in things that can’t be seen. People who deny what their faculties tell them in order to keep hold of some fantasy. But, this isn’t what the authors of the New Testament meant when they used the word “faith”. And it certainly isn’t how Jesus led his life or expected others to think about the things he said and the requirements he made.

It would be one thing if Jesus walked around, teaching to the people, and telling them “hey, man. You just gotta believe I’m God”. But, that’s not what he did. All of the things he did that we’ve discussed above – the miracles, the predicting of the future, dying and then returning to life – these things were all done to give evidence to back up his claims. And he did these things (apart from the resurrection) before he claimed to be God. In one interaction with the Pharisees, Jesus tells them “I told you, and you do not believe. The works that I do in my Father’s name bear witness about me,” (John 10:25). John even tells us towards the end of his gospel that Jesus did so many things to show who he was that they couldn’t all be written down. But, the ones John wrote were documented so that we would believe (John 20:30-31).

One of the best examples of Jesus being an evidentialist is in an interaction with the disciples of John the Baptist. It occurs in both Matthew 11:1-5 and Luke 7:18-22. John has been sitting in the prison of Herod Antipas. And he starts to have doubts about who he thought Jesus was. So, he sent some of his disciples to Jesus to ask him if he was the one everyone was waiting for or if John got it wrong.

Now, remember; John was Jesus’ cousin. And, John had witnessed the Holy Spirit descending upon Jesus, heard God speak from Heaven, and heard him declare Jesus his son with whom he was well-pleased. So, John had already seen a lot. Jesus could have very easily said to John’s disciples “just go tell John to have faith”. I wouldn’t have blamed him if he got a little offended, honestly. He could have reminded the disciples of all the things John had witnessed and reprimanded him for his doubt.

What did Jesus do instead? He gave them more evidence. He turned them into eyewitnesses of who he was. In front of them, he healed blindness and leprosy, made the lame walk, and raised people from the dead. After he did these things, he told John’s followers “now go and tell John what you have seen and heard“. In other words, give him the evidence.

Jesus Gave Evidence That He Was God

Jesus made some pretty wild claims about who he was. The good news for us is he actually backed those claims up with evidence. In fact, during his ministry he gave the evidence before he started making his claims to be God. He didn’t walk around telling everyone they “just have to have faith”. No, he performed many miracles as evidence to back up his claims – the greatest being his resurrection from the dead.

Christianity is a world view based on historical evidence. Not on blind faith. And, it all starts with examining the life of Jesus of Nazareth as recorded in the eyewitness testimony of the people who were there.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

About the Author: David W. Gilmore

Dave Gilmore is the founder and editor-in-chief of Legati Christi. Over the past few years he has developed a passion for Christian Apologetics and theology, and enjoys talking to others about the Christian world view

news via inbox

Nulla turp dis cursus. Integer liberos  euismod pretium faucibua


  1. davvy April 12, 2023 at 8:28 am - Reply

    this article is flawed in its approach to the existence of Christ. Jesus was 100% real based on historical account corelating what he did at certain points. This does not argue anything against the fact that the claims of miracles are outlandish are could be nothing more than flawed testimony.
    How can it be verified that these things happened when countless times through human history people have claimed to do crazy things and some people have also claimed to see crazy things. This does not translate to truth, and it is wrong to treat it as truth when it clearly cannot be confirmed to that extent.

    • David W. Gilmore April 14, 2023 at 6:11 am - Reply

      Hi davvy,

      Thank you for your thoughtful comment.

      Why do you think that the claims are outlandish? You also say that he claims _could_ be nothing more than flawed testimony. Do you think that their testimony is flawed? If so, why? You bring up the requirement of verification. How would you propose we verify these things apart from eyewitness testimony?

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.